Sole trader or limited company?

The trade-offs for an Amazon business, and why the tax answer is rarely the whole answer.

7 min read

This is the first structural decision most sellers face and the one most often decided on a half-remembered rule of thumb. The tax comparison genuinely matters, but it is not the only axis, and for a stock-holding importing business it is frequently not the decisive one.

How each is taxed

A sole trader is not separate from the business. Profits are yours as they arise and are taxed through Self Assessment at income tax rates, with Class 4 National Insurance on top. You are taxed on profit whether or not you take the money out, which for a business ploughing everything back into stock can mean a tax bill considerably larger than the cash available to pay it.

A limited company is a separate legal person. It pays corporation tax on its profits - 19% on profits up to £50,000 and 25% above £250,000, with marginal relief in between - and you are then taxed personally on what you extract, whether as salary, dividends or a mixture. The usual approach is a modest salary plus dividends, with dividends taxed at lower rates than salary but paid out of profits that have already borne corporation tax.

The headline comparison usually favours a company once profits are comfortably into five figures, but the margin is narrower than it was: the dividend allowance has fallen to £500, dividend rates have risen, and the small profits rate reintroduced a band structure that rewards keeping profits modest. Anyone quoting you a fixed crossover figure is guessing, because the answer depends on how much you need to extract.

The genuine advantage for a growth-stage Amazon business is retention. A company lets you leave profit inside the business, taxed once at corporation tax rates, to fund the next container. A sole trader pays full personal tax on that profit whether it is reinvested or not.

Liability, and why it matters more here than elsewhere

A sole trader is personally liable for the debts of the business without limit. For a consultant with no stock and no creditors this is close to theoretical. For an Amazon seller it is not: you may be placing five-figure orders with overseas suppliers, committing to freight, and carrying product liability on goods you did not manufacture.

Product liability is the one that deserves thought. If something you imported and sold injures someone, a sole trader's exposure reaches their house. Limited liability is not absolute - directors can be personally liable for wrongful trading, and lenders routinely ask for personal guarantees which waive the protection entirely - but the default position is materially different.

This is also an insurance question rather than purely a structural one. Product liability cover is not expensive and is worth having under either structure.

The practical differences

Suppliers and freight forwarders take limited companies more seriously, particularly overseas manufacturers assessing whether to extend payment terms. Some wholesalers will only open trade accounts for companies. If your growth depends on credit terms, this is a real consideration and not a matter of vanity.

Against that, a company is more administration. Statutory accounts filed at Companies House, a corporation tax return, a confirmation statement, payroll if you take a salary, and a public record of your accounts and your registered office address. Your name and correspondence address appear on a searchable register, which some sellers dislike. Accountancy fees are correspondingly higher.

There is also a bookkeeping discipline point. A company's money is genuinely not yours, and taking it out informally creates a director's loan account with its own tax consequences if it goes overdrawn. Sellers who have been running personal and business finances loosely find incorporation forces a tidiness they may not have wanted but generally benefit from.

When to change, and how

The usual trigger points are profits comfortably exceeding what you need to live on, taking on meaningful supplier credit or import commitments, or reaching a scale where personal liability stops feeling abstract. Many sellers start as sole traders precisely because it is simple and reversible, and incorporate once the business has proved itself. That is a reasonable sequence.

Incorporating mid-stream is not merely a form-filling exercise. Stock and equipment transfer to the company at market value, which can crystallise a tax charge. Your Amazon seller account has to be updated, which is a process rather than a setting and can involve verification delays at an inconvenient moment. VAT registration does not simply carry across - a company is a new legal person and generally needs its own registration, though a transfer of the existing number is possible in some circumstances. Bank accounts, supplier accounts and insurance all need moving.

None of that is a reason not to do it. It is a reason to do it deliberately, at a quiet point in the trading year, with someone who has done it before - rather than in November because a forum post said you were paying too much tax.

Compare UK accountants

Browse the full directory by city, services and published pricing.

Browse the directory